Duty to Consult
Introduction
Queensland work health and safety law places a clear duty on persons conducting a business or undertaking to consult with workers about matters that affect their health and safety. The duty is not a tick box exercise. It is about creating a genuine two way process where information is shared, views are sought and those views are considered before decisions are made.
The duty to consult is set out in sections 47 to 49 of the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Queensland Government, 2011). It applies to all PCBUs and it is supported by the Work health and safety consultation, cooperation and coordination Code of Practice 2021 (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021). Understanding what consultation is, when it is required and how it must be done helps employers meet their legal obligations and build a safer workplace.
The Duty to Consult Under Section 47
Section 47 requires a PCBU to consult, so far as is reasonably practicable, with workers who carry out work for the business and who are, or are likely to be, directly affected by a matter relating to work health and safety (Queensland Government, 2011). The duty applies to the PCBU, not to individual workers.
Consultation is not the same as informing workers after a decision has been made. It also is not a vote. The PCBU must still make the final decision, but the decision must be informed by the consultation process. If a PCBU and workers have agreed to consultation procedures, those procedures must be followed and they must be consistent with the definition of consultation in section 48.
How to Consult Under Section 48
Section 48 defines the nature of consultation. It requires the PCBU to do the following (Queensland Government, 2011):
1. Share relevant information
Relevant information about the matter is shared with workers.
2. Provide a reasonable opportunity to take part
Workers are given a reasonable opportunity to express their views, raise work health or safety issues, and contribute to the decision-making process.
3. Take workers’ views into account
The views of workers are taken into account by the PCBU.
4. Advise workers of the outcome
The workers consulted are advised of the outcome in a timely way.
Meaningful consultation also requires the PCBU to identify who is affected, provide information early enough for workers to contribute, and allow time for consideration. The process should be accessible and workers must be able to contribute without fear of reprisal. Where workers are represented by a health and safety representative, consultation must involve that representative.
When Consultation Is Required Under Section 49
Section 49 sets out the specific health and safety matters where consultation is required (Queensland Government, 2011).
The matters that require consultation
Identifying hazards and assessing risks
Consultation is required when identifying hazards and assessing risks to health and safety arising from the work carried out, or to be carried out, by the business or undertaking (Queensland Government, 2011). Workers know the tasks and conditions that cause problems, incidents, injuries and near misses, so drawing on their experience, knowledge and ideas makes hazards more likely to be found and control measures more likely to work (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021).
Consultation is needed at each step of the risk management process. Workers should be encouraged to report hazards and health and safety problems immediately, so that risks can be managed before an incident occurs.
Deciding how to eliminate or minimise risks
Consultation is required when making decisions about the ways to eliminate or minimise those risks (Queensland Government, 2011). Workers who carry out the task often understand which controls will work in practice and which will not, so their input helps select control measures that are effective and are actually followed (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021).
Consultation does not mean telling workers about a decision after it has been made. Workers should be able to ask questions about health and safety, raise concerns and report problems, make safety recommendations and take part in the problem solving.
The adequacy of facilities for workers
Consultation is required when making decisions about the adequacy of facilities for the welfare of workers (Queensland Government, 2011). Facilities are things provided for the welfare of workers, for example toilets, drinking water, washing facilities, eating facilities, change rooms, personal storage and first aid (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021).
Consult workers and any representatives on what facilities are needed, such as the number and location of toilets, taking into account the number and composition of the workforce, the type of work, the nature of the hazards, and the size and location of the workplace. The consultation should include access, cleaning and maintenance, and any change that affects the adequacy of facilities already provided.
Proposing changes that may affect health or safety
Consultation is required when proposing changes that may affect the health or safety of workers (Queensland Government, 2011). Examples include changing work systems such as shift rosters, work procedures or the work environment, developing a new product or planning a new project, purchasing new or used equipment, using new substances, or restructuring the business (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021).
Consult as early as possible, while options are still open, so that workers views can shape the change rather than react to it after the decision is made.
Deciding on key WHS procedures
Consultation is required when making decisions about the procedures for consulting with workers, resolving work health or safety issues at the workplace, monitoring the health of workers, monitoring the conditions at the workplace, and providing information and training for workers (Queensland Government, 2011).
These procedures should be in writing to give clarity and certainty at the workplace, should set out the role of health and safety representatives, and should be easily accessible, for example on noticeboards or an intranet (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021).
Any other matter prescribed by regulation
Consultation is required when carrying out any other activity prescribed under a regulation for this section (Queensland Government, 2011). The WHS Regulation sets out further specific consultation requirements beyond the matters listed in section 49, so the duty is not limited to those five matters (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021).
It is also good practice to consult workers about health and safety matters that are not on the list. Regular consultation is better than consulting only as issues arise, because it lets problems be identified and fixed early.
Involve the Health and Safety Representative
Where workers are represented by a health and safety representative, the PCBU must consult with the HSR (Queensland Government, 2011). In some cases, consultation with the HSR alone may be sufficient to discharge the duty, depending on the issue and the work group (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021).
The PCBU must support the HSR to perform their functions, provide paid time for consultation and training, and share relevant health and safety information (Queensland Government, 2011). HSRs must not be disadvantaged or discriminated against for taking on the role. Involving HSRs early improves the quality of consultation and ensures consistent communication across the work group.
Reach Every Affected Worker
The duty to consult extends to all workers who carry out work for the business, including employees, contractors, labour hire workers, volunteers and trainees (Queensland Government, 2011). The PCBU must consider how to make consultation accessible to shift workers, remote workers and workers with different language needs.
Practical steps include choosing convenient times and locations, using appropriate language and formats, and providing confidential channels for feedback on sensitive issues such as psychosocial hazards (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021). The PCBU should ask workers how they want to be consulted and adapt arrangements to suit the workforce.
Consultation in a Toolbox Talk
A toolbox talk can be an effective forum for consultation when it is structured as a genuine discussion rather than a one way briefing (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021). The PCBU should present the relevant information, explain the issue and invite workers to share their views, experience and suggestions for controls.
The facilitator should record the points raised, explain how the views will be considered, and advise workers of the outcome once a decision is made. For recurring hazards or proposed changes, toolbox talks should be followed up with written confirmation so workers know what was decided and why.
Record the Consultation
Good record keeping demonstrates that consultation has occurred and that workers’ views were taken into account (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021). Records should show who was consulted, when and how, what information was shared, what views were raised, and what decision was made and why.
Records also support continuous improvement and provide evidence for regulators if required. A simple consultation register, meeting minutes, toolbox talk sign on sheets and action logs can be enough, provided they capture the key elements of the process and the outcome.
Conclusion
The duty to consult under sections 47 to 49 is a core part of Queensland WHS law (Queensland Government, 2011). It requires PCBUs to share information, provide a reasonable opportunity for workers to contribute, take views into account and communicate outcomes. When consultation is done well it leads to better risk controls and stronger safety culture.
Embedding consultation into everyday practices such as toolbox talks, team meetings and change processes ensures the duty is met consistently. With clear procedures, inclusive engagement and good records, PCBUs can meet their legal obligations and work with workers to build safer workplaces (Workplace Health and Safety Queensland, 2021).
References
Queensland Government. (2011). Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld), sections 46 to 49, 70 and 72. Queensland Legislation. https://www.legislation.qld.gov.au/view/html/inforce/current/act-2011-018
Workplace Health and Safety Queensland. (2021). Work health and safety consultation, cooperation and coordination Code of Practice 2021. Queensland Government. https://www.worksafe.qld.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0026/72647/whs-consultation-cooperation-coordination-cop-2021.pdf



